SU is a big Joe Girardi fan. Being a manager in New York with all the media outlets and the constant second-guessing is a real challenge. He is a smart guy, protects his players and tolerates the media as best he can. Joe Torre was the master with the media – Mr. Smooth – and always comfortable chit-chatting with them. Girardi does what is required but you can see him bolt off the stage after the post-game press conferences. Not his thing.
If the Yankees don’t make it to October this year, it will be 3 years in a row. They have the oldest roster in MLB and a bench of utility infielders. His starters are creaky and he has to juggle a 6-man rotation with generally only 6 innings of production. SU believes he does a masterful job and that they have over-achieved to date. This is a flawed team offensively. Plus he has to play Stephen Drew every day. It cannot be easy writing that name in each day.
Brian Cashman has had an incredible run in New York and has the trust and confidence of Hal Steinbrenner. He will be under pressure to consider a new manager next season. SU says Hal should take a look at Dave Dombrowski and see if the Yankees should consider a change at the GM position instead of manager. There are finally some pieces at the higher levels of the minor leagues but the Yankees are now stuck with Headley and Ellsbury for years to come. Headley is serviceable on a deep roster but for a guy with that many at bats, he drives in so few runs. Ellsbury can’t stay healthy and is just not worth $22 million a year. SU fears Girardi’s job is at risk if the Yankees collapse down the stretch but it’s not his fault. Time will tell.
Some also believe that the Mets need to make the playoffs this year to save Terry Collins’ job. That may be true but it’s not like he was given a world beating roster this year. However, now that they are up 2.5 games in the standings, expectations are on the rise. They are a nice story and if the Yankees falter, they will have the spotlight for the next 6 weeks.