Show the Shifts on TV

SU only caught the end of last night’s Yankee game but I make the following observation. Michael Kay will often reference the nature of the shift but they rarely show how the fielders are positioned on TV. It’s interesting to see exactly what the hitter sees when he steps to the plate.

Case in point. In the 9th inning, Anthony Rizzo is up with one out and the Yankees down 2 runs. In this instance, they did show the shift. 4 outfielders, one infielder on the left side of the infield near 2nd base and the 2nd baseman playing softball style in short right field. So, what’s the objective if you are Rizzo? Um, get on base right? So, he bunted down the 3rd base line – perfect. Ball skipped past 3rd base into foul territory. Heady play to bring the tying run to the plate with Judge on deck.

When you go to a game in person, you see the shifts on every play. It is striking how much of the field the defense leaves open. And it is equally striking how most hitters – and I put that in the 99% category – ignore the shifts. SU knows it’s hard to hit a 98 mph fastball exactly where you want it but the opportunity is staring you in the face. It is very frustrating to watch the Yankee “sluggers” hit into the shift over and over again. Smart money says that if you go the other way, teams will alter their defensive strategy. I guess there isn’t much smart money in baseball these days.

The broadcasts should show the defense alignment more often. It really is interesting and amazingly frustrating for fans to observe how hitters attack it.

A lot of talk today about John Sterling’s inaccurate home run call with Stanton up and the team down 2 runs last night in the 8th inning. He went into his “It is high, it is far, it is GONE” call and naturally, the ball was caught on the warning track. Long-time Yankee fans are used to this. If you are ever listening in the car, you learn to wait – and listen to the crowd – as he can’t be trusted. SU actually doesn’t care anymore. He is 80-something years old and unlistenable. It’s better to follow on mlb.com on the phone and avoid the radiocast. And it’s nothing to do with age – this has been an issue for a long, long time.

Is Gerrit Cole still an ace? Or without Spider-tac, is he just another hard thrower? SU says it’s still just April and you have to give him some time to round into form. He’s a smart dude and will figure it out.

Should Kershaw been allowed to finish his perfect game yesterday? Temperatures in the mid-30s and only 80 pitchers through 7 innings. SU says it was the right decision to pull him. Even with Gary Sanchez probably coming up again which makes the job easier. This is a guy with a history of arm problems, and you can’t risk the whole season in early April with his track record. Sure, a perfect game is a big deal but we all remember Santana on the Mets who blew out his arm completing a no hitter. The Dodgers’ manager made the right call there.

4 thoughts on “Show the Shifts on TV”

  1. Smart at bat by Rizzo – not surprised as he is an intelligent player. He should have been running out of the box though.
    Cole is definitely an ace. Pretty sure he will have a strong season.
    Absolutely the right move to pull Kershaw – and he said all the right things after the game.
    Time for Stanton to play somewhere else in my opinion.

  2. The fact that MLB is banning the shift is mortifying. To your point, you position your defense a certain way, and if the other team is good enough to beat you, so be it. If you want the bad news bears Cool Carl Karanski Shift (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrjJFNDQJbM), do it. (by the way, Coach Buttermaker was way ahead of his time with this). If I am the opposition, I need to adapt.

    I would have left Kershaw keep going until he lost the perfect game. 80 pitches, nothing above 90 mph. He;s going to have arm trouble in a few months anyway, and he gave up a chance at baseball immortality

  3. 100% right move on Kershaw.

    Cano has been going the other way against the shift also this year in a small sample. An old PED user but still a talented hitter. Not easy to hit em where they ain’t but you do what you have to do to win.
    You should be allowed to play defense wherever you want. I hope the rule change with a mid field line does not go into affect. There are much better ways to improve the game without fundamentally changing it.

  4. So I agree with everything you said. Is Vlad a beast???? He carried the Blue jays easily to the victory. Springer looked pretty good too. We should have gotten Sprunger. :George” would have gotten him.. With the Yankees philosophy since the passing away of Steinbrenner our budget has been the doom of our not winning World Series. I says one thing about Cashman. he’s a good General manager, but not a great one. A team like Tampa Bay must be geniuses year in after year out. When was the last time the Yankees were truly overachievers? maybe 3 years ago when we picked up Urshella and LeMahieu along with some key minor leaguers. With most teams using the shift and now the 4 man outfield I guess the frustration the Yankee fans have must be the same throughout the country.

Leave a reply to Josh Wilson Cancel reply