There are a lot of things to like about Joakim Noah.  He plays with fire, has a lot of energy and is all about the team.  He is a pass-first type of player which in the NBA puts you in a 1% category of all players.  But on this Knick team as currently configured, he is not a good fit.

The basic problem is that when he is on the court with Porzingis, he plays the 5 and KP is at the 4.  So, on defense, Porzingis has to run all over the court and picks up fouls against smaller and more mobile players.  At the 5, he can help out more as a rim protector and given the lack of big-time post players in the NBA, he rarely has to cover scorers at that position.  The other problem is that on offense, with Melo, KP and Noah on the court, there is just not a lot of ball movement and things get clogged up.

Noah can be traded starting tomorrow (I believe free agents who were signed in the off-season can be moved starting December 15th), and some team will see value in him.  SU says make a move and while you’re at it, maybe some team would like Carmelo.

Last night, Hornacek put in some odd line up of bench players and Porzingis in the 4th quarter and they went on a 19-4 run to take the lead.  Rookie Ron Baker was playing the point and, of course, the ball moved, the players ran the court and KP was the focal point of the offense.  This dude is just so good and so versatile.  Unfortunately, he got into foul trouble as the guards could not keep Bledsoe out of the paint.  Btw, Bledoe is really good.

Anyway, 4 minutes left in the game, and you knew what was going to happen.  You knew it.  Anthony, who was having a bad game, and shot 3 for 15 overall, became the focal point of the offense and the ball stopped moving, they broke out the Mike Woodson offense, and eventually lost in OT.  SU was impressed with Phoenix which down the stretch double-teamed Melo when he got the ball.  I do not understand why other teams don’t do this as he is not a willing passer.  I know, I know – he’s a “great passer.”  Only when he wants to be and he doesn’t want to be one most of the time.

It’s just a loss on a long West Coast road trip.  Rose was out with back spasms again (not a good sign by the way and needs watching) but every night you see how good Porzingis can be and he is entertaining.  Build around him and put a roster together that takes advantage of his skills.  SU sounds like a broken record but the Knicks will never become an elite team until you move Anthony and change the style.  This team has some nice pieces and is fun to watch in stretches. O’Quinn is a nice player off the bench and should get more minutes. Note to Phil Jackson: we are all waiting.

The Jim Harbaugh rumors to the LA Rams just do not make any sense.  He is already paid a lot at Michigan and the reality is that he will have an NFL job waiting for him whenever he wants to go back.  At least a third of coaches get fired every off season.  Harbaugh who is unfiltered told his team that “this talk is coming from our enemies”, and said there are three coaches who are telling recruits that he is leaving to help them land those athletes.  SU is guessing it’s: Michigan State; Ohio State; and Penn State but I could be wrong.  He does make it interesting.  He won’t leave until he wins something like a Big Ten championship.  He hasn’t won anything yet and is coaching the LA Rams the dream job?

As a long-time NY Giants’ fan, SU was excited to see a defensive performance against Dallas that hearkened back to the days of Lawrence Taylor and Harry Carson.  Even with JPP out, this kid from Notre Dame showed his game on national television and all of a sudden, there was actually a pass rush.

Eli did just enough on offense (and I mean just enough) and OBJ finally caught one of those passes and took it to the house.  He dropped another sure TD pass in the 1st half but I guess with him you take the good with the bad.  You have to figure the game a success if he can avoid an unsportsmanlike penalty.  Dak Prescott was exposed a bit and all of a sudden, the Cowboys may have a quarterback controversy with a healthy Tony Romo waiting in the wings.  This was his 2nd game in a row of non-productivity on 3rd down.  The NFL is unforgiving as we all know and he will no doubt be feeling the pressure next Sunday night against Tampa Bay at home this time.

The Giants secondary is really excellent and you have to give Defensive Coordinator Steve Spagnuolo a ton of credit for making his defensive unit better with each successive week.  If they can ever develop a consistent running game which you need in the colder weather come playoff time, they could be a real threat.  SU is still not seeing much in that regard but defensively, they should be in most games.  Eli needs more time in the pocket and he is still prone to make the blind pass in the 4th quarter but luckily Dallas dropped the interception possibility.

Combine this with a strong Knicks performance on the West Coast in a win over the Lakers, it was a good NY sports night.  Melo cleared the air with Phil Jackson and had 5 assists in the 1st quarter alone.  Connection there?

OK, so we know that the Yankees needed a closer for next season.  Betances did not look like closer material in September and can’t even throw the ball to any of the bases.  He may never be that “guy” who closes things out which is fine – although not for him as he will miss out on millions of dollars.  Chapman is a stud – no doubt.  But 5 years for a relief pitcher?  You do not see contracts like that anywhere and we know that aside from Mariano, relievers are up and down from year-to-year.

On the other hand, it’s not my money and clearly Hal Steinbrenner likes this guy a lot and assuming the plan is to be contenders starting in 2018, you do need a closer.  But here’s the thing: a couple of years ago, the Red Sox signed some big name free agents and the Yankees panicked and grabbed Ellsbury for 8 years at $22 million a year or something like that.  Three years later, we know that this may be the worst contract in baseball and it’s just a matter of time before the Yankees move him and end up paying 80% of his salary for the duration of the contract.  After the Sales trade, the Chapman signing feels the same way.  Too much money, too many years, panic move.

SU is excited about the Yankees for 2017 and would be really excited if they can move Chase Headley before then.  I know Ellsbury is untradeable but let’s open up 3rd base and slide some prospect in there.  SU cannot endure another year of 10 homeruns and 52 rbis for an everyday player.  Can’t do it.

I had a laugh-out-loud moment a couple of days ago when I read that Rajon Rondo had been suspended for one game for conduct detrimental to the team.  Now, who would have ever thought that could happen?  The Knicks dodged a bullet there by not signing him even though Melo was lobbying for him.  He is the Demarcus Cousins of point guards.  Never happy.

Did you see that Phil Jackson called Melo a ball hog?  Shocking.  SU only caught a few minutes of last night’s Knick game (once a lead hits 80 points I call it a night) but Jeff Van Gundy went off defending Melo’s assist numbers and how they were much higher than Porzingis.  SU note to Van Gundy: Porzingis needs to shoot every time he touches the ball as Carmelo and Rose are going to shoot it every time they get it.  I don’t even want him passing it.  Van Gundy knows better and Anthony is a ball stopper.

SU fave Novak Djokovic has parted ways with his coach, Boris Becker.  He appears to be under the “influence” of some guru these days who espouses tranquility and balance.  Not a good combo if you want to be #1 in the world.  This is not good.

Finally, how abou the UConn women winning easily over Notre Dame on their home court?  This is supposedly a down year for Auriemma while he reloads but he is such a good coach.  What he is accomplishing in this era is very impressive.

So, the rich just got richer in the AL East.  The Red Sox traded a bunch of prospects to get the premier free agent pitcher on the market this winter.  After getting David Price last year, they can add Sale and already have the Cy  Young award winner in Porcello.

SU does not love the long-term, $30 million a year contracts and is fine that the Yankees are not playing in that space.  Cashman has some extra prospects but may be waiting another year when the free agent picks will be a bit more robust.

Are the Red Sox the “beasts of the East?”

SU forgot to mention this about the Giant game yesterday.  It’s possible the game plan by McAdoo was a scientific experiment based on the following principles.  The theory was: is it possible to win an NFL game without any consistent running threat and throwing every single pass to Beckham?  And I do mean every single pass.  This was the plan in the 2nd half for sure.  Over and over again.

And is it necessary to claim pass interference on every play and get all hot and bothered on every tackle?  Plus, and this made SU very unhappy, what was that Instagram posting which must have taken place Saturday night where OBJ and Antonio Brown of the Steelers were together yukking it up somewhere?  Has football now become the David Ortiz big hug sport?  And how would that make OBJ’s teammates on defense feel?  I do not get this – not in a sport that is as violent as the NFL.

Did this bother anyone else?

While SU was clearly hoping to see Michigan sneak into the top 4 of the college football playoffs, the wins by Washington and Clemson made that impossible.  Washington was impressive in its win over Colorado and while Clemson’s defense was exposed by Virginia Tech, they managed to hang on.  Penn State clearly made a case with its Big Ten championship but they only had that one win over Ohio State in an otherwise weak schedule this year and they were not deserving.  SU still says that if the goal was to have the 4 best teams in the playoffs, then Michigan should be in there but you really can’t make that case based on the weekend’s results.  Onward and upward.

SU must make a comment about Cam Newton.  This guy is not always giving it his all.  I have watched him a fair amount this year given that the SU Fantasy Team has Greg Olsen on its roster who really is an All-Pro quality player at tight end.  Newton strikes me as a guy who is not studying the film of what works and doesn’t work but rather heaves the ball downfield and puts it up for grabs time and time again.  Aside from ignoring Olsen, at times it appears that he is disinterested out there.  Clearly, he has a lot of talent but to me, he is high maintenance and high risk.  In a word: over-rated and not deserving of all the attention.

The Yankees signing of Matt Holliday is interesting.  SU likes the 1-year contract in terms of not being obligated longer term for an older player (37).  He is a good clubhouse guy and tries hard.  But he is also a big-time swing and miss type of hitter who likes to pull the ball.  He did well with St. Louis but is coming off an injury plagued season.  Last time I checked, the short wall at Yankee Stadium is in right field.  Shouldn’t the DH be a left-handed hitter?  Are there not better choices out there?  Holliday is the type of hitter who surprises me when he gets a hit a la Brian McCann.  I will be happy to be proven wrong but unless they are going to get another lefty hitter with power, I am not sure about this move.

Finally, I caught a little of last night’s Knick game and DeMarcus Cousins.  Mike Breen said he had a “monster game” but tell me if this is “monster game” worthy: 9 for 30 from the field, 14 – 16 from the foul line, 12 rebounds, 36 points.  You have to figure that’s 30 shot attempts plus another 7 or 8 where he was fouled.  These are Kobe Bryant shot volume type numbers.  He took 10 3-pointers.  Bottom line: this guy is a ball hog and is always unhappy on the court.  A great talent but not someone who makes his teammates better.  Sound familiar?

Happy December, everyone.  I am not sure what it is but SU has a much better handle on the sports world as of this morning.  Let me share with you:

• First of all, SU needs to be on Twitter.  I realize that I have a lot to say at all times and SU must be heard.  Note to SU staff: let’s get to work on that.
• Second, MLB and the Players’ Union have reached a deal and this is going to open up the trade and free agent market bigly.  Brian Cashman has been waiting to see this resolved.  In short order, you will see:
  • the signing of Aroldis Chapman for much, much too money as the closer as the Yankees have no confidence that Betances has the head for that role
  • the signing of Carlos Beltran which SU is against OR the signing of Mike Napoli of the Indians.  I think it comes down to how much confidence they have in Greg Bird being able to regain the form of late 2014.  Apparently, he struggled mightily in the Arizona Fall League.  Napoli can fill both the DH and first base roles.  SU says go young and stick with Bird
  • a trade for a starting pitcher as Cashman starts to use some of his prospects.  I don’t think he will sign a big ticket free agent pitcher for way too much money.  Been there, done that.  Does not work and certainly not for the last few years of the contract
• Third, SU has seen the future of the Knicks last night in the late 3rd quarter and early part of the 4th quarter and it was great.  Noah was out with an injury and Courtney Lee had sprained his ankle.  Hornacek had KP out there with all the young guys plus Jennings at the point.  They built a healthy 17-point lead in no time and it was great fun to watch.  Of course, when the lead shrunk a bit, he brought Melo and Rose back in and it was very predictable from there as momentum and ball movement were lost.  But here’s the thing: he benched Rose for the last few minutes and while Melo was the hero with his game winner, he had bricked his last few shots before then.  This will be good long-term as Rose will be pissed off and knows that he is not guaranteed minutes.  He is really a 2-guard; passing just does not come naturally to him while Jennings is playing the best of his career and amazingly unselfishly.  The offense just does not flow with Rose who is looking to drive and shoot first and the pass is really a last resort for him.  Phil Jackson has a chance to move Rose and Noah/Melo and really set them up long-term before he heads back out West.
• And finally, regarding the college football rankings, it’s pretty apparent that if Washington and/or Clemson lose this weekend, Michigan moves up to the top 4 where quite frankly they belong.  The committee has said that it’s their job to put the 4 best teams in the playoffs.  They also said that as of today, the difference between Michigan and Washington is razor thin.  I believe that if Washington wins unimpressively, they could even slip to 5th.  Plus think about it: you could have a rematch of Ohio State and Michigan either in the semis or finals.  If their goal is to make money for the NCAA, this is a pay-per-view type bonanza.  Highest rated game of all time with Super Bowl type numbers.

Anyway, just wanted to share my rant with you this morning.  Feel free to weigh in.  And always happy to hear from others as well vs. the usual suspects.

The Knicks game against OKC last night had a lot of buzz going for it.  We learned that Derrick Rose and Russell Westbrook have worked out together in the off-season for the last 10 years and are good friends.  Clearly, they were looking to get the better of the game on a personal level.  The pace was quick and Westbrook recorded another triple double and even threatened a quadruple double but fell short with only 7 turnovers.

SU believes that Rose had 3 assists mid-way through the 1st quarter and finished with 4.  He took 20 shots and 10 foul shots for his 30 points and was an offensive force with a series of fearless drives to the hoop.  His outside shot still looks odd to me – very flat – but he made a few.  But here are the issues according to SU:

• He was all 1 on 1.  Completely.  SU believes he either needs to have his eyes checked as he can’t see his teammates or he has zero interest in passing and is using this season to secure his next contract somewhere else.  And there were guys open.  At one point, Porzingis stood in the corner with his hands out-stretched high while Rose was triple-teamed in the lane.  No pass.  Hard to not see that.
• Carmelo was 4 for 19 and quite frankly, it felt worse than that.  The sophisticated NY fans have started to boo him loudly now – not when he misses but when he holds the ball in isolation and starts his jab step routine.  It seemed like every shot came in a 1 0n 1 situation.
• Down the stretch in the 4th quarter, Rose and Melo played a 2-man game on most possessions.  Porzingis is their best player now (SU has done the research and found this to be true) and yet he does not touch the ball for long periods of the game.
• SU likes the way that Jeff Hornacek does not call plays – he trusts his guys on the court.  During the Pat Riley regime in NY, every possession was called by him to make sure Ewing got his 25 shots a night.  Hornacek likes an up and down tempo which is good for the fans.
• Noah is just a bad fit with Porzingis.  Porzingis is best when matched with the 5 man on the other team.  This was a bad free agent signing for this roster.
• SU likes Holiday, Jennings (never ever thought I would say that but he is a new man) and the youngsters.  But Rose needs to get others involved and I am afraid that continued offensive success will help him and hurt the team.

Soon, Jeremy Lin will be back in action and I will turn my attention to the woeful Nets who play hard and pass the ball.  I really like KP and will stay interested but I was very frustrated last night.

Finally, SU awaits the college football playoff seedings.  I know Michigan is a 2-loss team and the loss to Iowa is killer for them.  But they beat both Penn State and Wisconsin this year as well as Colorado, and if Washington loses to USC on Friday night, or if Clemson somehow loses to Virginia Tech, SU believes that Michigan should be that 4th seeded team assuming that Ohio State gets all the love from the experts.  Anyone agree?

Clearly, SU had a rooting interest in today’s Ohio State – Michigan game.  Michigan dominated the game and made its share of turnovers to keep Ohio State in the game despite Michigan’s heroic effort on defense.  But it’s a shame when the game comes down to a few penalty calls and non-calls plus the replay officials lacking the guts to overturn a spot on what would have been a game ending play in OT.

If you watch a lot of Big Ten football like SU week in and week out, you know that the Big Ten officials are bad – they are just bad.  For a major conference that draws hundreds of thousands of fans to its games each season, you would think they could do better.  Today was just another example of that and Michigan paid the price.

It’s true: the QB handed OSU 14 points on turnovers and that was a killer.  But in OT, a non-call on pass interference when lesser calls went against Michigan like that all day was a huge play.

Ohio State has now escaped three times this season in close games and they are not likely to win the championship.  But you need to ref the game fairly in the rivalry games and it’s a shame it came down to this in the end.  SU still enjoys the journey of the season and life will go on as we know it.  But the Big Ten should be embarrassed.

SU just watched what was an exciting Knicks game resulting in a win over the Blazers.  Derrick Rose made a couple of tough shots down the stretch but here’s the deal.  Porzingis was great – 31 points and scoring from all over in the 2nd half.  Rose was in foul trouble and Brandon Jennings was great with 11 assists.  But then for the final 5 minutes, every possession and I mean every possession was Rose and Melo playing a 2-man game and basically freezing everyone else out.  Porzingis had no touches in the last 5 minutes.  Outrageous.  Rose went 1 on 1 every possession or passed to Melo who must have shot 7 for 23.

The Knicks got great contributions from the other 2 Euro players and SU is beginning to really like those guys.  This could be a fun team to watch.  But tonight, you could even hear the Knick fans booing Melo when he stopped the ball down the stretch to do his thing instead of moving the ball which is what got them in position to win in the first place.

SU says: trade Melo.  It’s time and you know what?  Package him with Rose.  Go with the youngsters and Jennings who has played incredibly unselfishly this year for him.  The entire rest of the team plays unselfishly.  You can hear the fans and their anticipation – these are smart fans.  They want the ball to move.  Rose is a backcourt ball stopper and Melo is a front court version.  Phil Jackson: you are out of here shortly.  Leave the fans with hope and clean house now.

Am I right?